Guthrie's Famous Pizza in Oklahoma City: Coal-Fired Crust and Local Loyalty

Guthrie's Famous Pizza is a coal-fired pizzeria in Guthrie, Oklahoma, roughly 30 miles north of downtown Oklahoma City, that has operated since 1997 and draws regulars from across the metro area for its char-marked crust and straightforward menu of traditional pies.

What Guthrie's Famous Pizza actually is

The restaurant operates from a standalone building on West Warner Avenue in Guthrie's downtown corridor. The coal-fired oven is the centerpiece: it burns hot enough to cook pizzas in under two minutes, creating a thin, crispy crust with deep brown spots that define the place's signature look. The operation is counter-service, with seating inside and occasional outdoor tables depending on weather. It's not a full-service sit-down restaurant; order at the counter, wait for your pie, and eat on premises or take it with you. The clientele spans families with kids, date-night couples, and Guthrie residents stopping in for a quick lunch.

Pizza styles and pricing

Guthrie's Famous Pizza makes New York-style pies: 14-inch and 16-inch rounds with a thin, foldable base and a wood-fired crust that's slightly charred but not blackened. Signature offerings include the Vegetarian (mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives), the Meat Lovers (pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon), and the Margherita (fresh mozzarella, basil, tomato sauce). Specialty pies run $17 to $24 depending on size and topping count. A plain cheese 14-inch is typically under $13. Individual slices are available at lunch for $2.50 to $4 each. Wings and appetizers (garlic knots, breadsticks) fill out the menu without overshadowing the core focus on pizza. Soft drinks, beer, and wine are available. Pricing holds steady year-round, but it's wise to call (405-282-0555 or verify via their social media) to confirm current pricing before a special order.

How Guthrie's Famous Pizza compares to Oklahoma City pizza options

Oklahoma City's pizza landscape splits roughly between casual chains (Domino's, Papa John's) and independent pizzerias. Among local competitors, Ted's Cafe Escondido in Edmond offers Neapolitan-style pizza with a longer cook time and a slightly softer, airier crust than Guthrie's thinner New York profile. Pizza Shuttle locations across OKC serve a thicker, dough-forward pie closer to a pan or tavern style. Goro Ramen + Izakaya downtown does wood-fired pizza as part of a broader Japanese-influenced menu, making it better for diners who want pizza as one option among many. Choose Guthrie's Famous Pizza if you want a fast, no-frills coal-fired New York slice; choose Ted's if you prefer a puffy, lighter Neapolitan crust and a longer dining experience; pick Pizza Shuttle for a casual, delivery-friendly thicker pie. Guthrie's sits between high-end pizzerias and chain options in price and formality.

Who it suits and who it does not suit

Guthrie's Famous Pizza works best for families with children, groups of friends wanting quick, shareable food, and OKC metro residents willing to drive north for a specific craving. The counter-service model and short cook time make it ideal for lunch or casual weeknight dinner. It does not suit diners seeking a full-service restaurant experience, reservations, table service, or an extensive wine list. Vegetarians have solid options (Vegetarian pie, custom veggie builds), but the menu is meat-friendly overall. Those on very tight budgets may find specialty pies pricey compared to chain pizza, though per-slice purchases keep costs lower for small appetites.

What the first visit involves

Walk in, review the menu board above the counter, and order. You can customize any pie or order a signature build. Payment is typically cash or card at the register. Most pizzas cook in 90 seconds to two minutes; the staff will call your name or number when it's ready. Grab a box, find a seat, and eat. If the weather is good, outdoor seating may be available. Don't expect a host or server. Parking is street-level in downtown Guthrie with no formal lot, though spaces are usually available on and near Warner Avenue.

Hours and logistics

Guthrie's Famous Pizza is open Monday through Thursday 10:30 a.m. to 9 p.m., Friday and Saturday 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m., and Sunday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. (verify current hours by phone, as holiday and seasonal closures occur). The location is at 126 West Warner Avenue, Guthrie, Oklahoma, about a 45-minute drive from downtown OKC depending on traffic. There is no delivery. Takeout and dine-in are both available; many regulars order ahead by phone to minimize wait times.

Guthrie's Famous Pizza has sustained its reputation for over 25 years by keeping the focus narrow: coal-fired crust, fresh toppings, and consistency. For OKC-area residents, the drive is worthwhile if coal-fired New York-style pizza is what you're after.