Empire Slice Shop in Oklahoma City: New York Slice in the Mayfair Village Strip
Empire Slice Shop is a counter-service pizzeria in the Mayfair Village shopping center that specializes in New York-style slices and whole pies, operating with a focused menu and quick turnaround suited to lunch crowds and casual evening stops.
What Empire Slice Shop actually is
Empire Slice Shop runs a stripped-down operation: you order at the counter, collect your slice or pie, and eat at one of a handful of tables or take it elsewhere. The format mirrors traditional New York slice shops where volume and speed matter more than table service. The space occupies a modest storefront in Mayfair Village, a strip center in northwest Oklahoma City that also hosts other casual dining and retail. The shop does not take reservations and does not deliver; it functions as a walk-in destination for people in or near the shopping center.
Menu, pricing, and what to order
Empire Slice Shop sells individual slices and whole 18-inch pies. A single slice runs approximately $3 to $4 depending on toppings, while a whole cheese pie costs around $16 to $18. Pepperoni, sausage, veggie, and specialty combinations are available. The dough is standard New York style: thin crust with enough structure to fold, baked in a gas deck oven. Slices are cut large enough that two pieces constitute a meal for most people. Whole pies work for groups or for taking home; the shop boxes pies to go without requiring advance notice.
Confirm current pricing by calling ahead, as ingredient costs fluctuate seasonally.
How it stacks against Oklahoma City pizza options
Oklahoma City has multiple pizza styles represented across neighborhoods. Pizzerias Pizzeria in Midtown focuses on wood-fired Neapolitan pies with longer cook times and premium ingredients, landing in a different price range ($20 and up for a whole pie) and appeal—craft-focused, sit-down, less convenient for a quick lunch. Ted's Cafe Escondido and chains like Domino's and Papa John's serve delivery-first models with thicker crusts and broader menu scope, but lack the speed and simplicity of a slice-focused counter shop. Empire Slice Shop occupies the niche of New York-style quick pizza: you walk in, get a slice in under five minutes, and move on. It suits someone in Mayfair Village or nearby who wants a familiar format without ordering ahead.
Who it suits and who it does not
Empire Slice Shop works best for weekday lunch, afternoon snacks, and casual solo or small-group meals. The counter format and limited seating make it poor for groups larger than four or for anyone expecting a lingering dining experience. It does not cater or take large advance orders. People seeking a full-service restaurant, draft beer, or a destination-dinner atmosphere should look elsewhere. It serves people who know what they want, work or live nearby, and value speed over ambiance.
What the first visit involves
Walk in during operating hours, survey the slice case at the counter, and point to what you want or order a whole pie. The staff boxes or plates it immediately. If eating in, find a table; if taking out, grab napkins from the counter. Seating is limited and does not fill quickly during off-peak hours, but lunch hour (11:30 a.m. to 1 p.m.) can produce a short line. Cash and card are both accepted.
Hours, location, and parking
Empire Slice Shop operates in the Mayfair Village shopping center at [specific address to be confirmed locally]. Hours are typically Monday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., and Sunday 12 p.m. to 8 p.m.; confirm these before a visit, as retail hours shift seasonally. Parking is free and shared with the shopping center; the storefront has direct lot access. The location is accessible by car from northwest Oklahoma City neighborhoods and is not served by public transit.
Empire Slice Shop fills a straightforward need: reliable New York-style pizza by the slice in a walkable shopping center, without pretense or wait times. In a city where pizza leans toward delivery chains or craft wood-fired formats, it offers a third option that works for lunch and impulse visits.
