ShortyCakes Bakery in Oklahoma City: Custom Cakes and Pastries with Extended Hours

ShortyCakes Bakery is a full-service cake and pastry shop in Oklahoma City that specializes in custom decorated cakes for events alongside a rotating selection of fresh pastries and desserts for daily walk-in customers.

What ShortyCakes Actually Is

ShortyCakes operates as both a made-to-order cake studio and a retail bakery counter. The business handles custom cake orders for birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, and corporate events, while also stocking fresh pastries, cookies, brownies, and seasonal items for customers who want something the same day. The scale is small enough that owners are typically present during operating hours, which matters if you need to discuss cake design details or troubleshoot a custom order.

Custom Cakes, Pricing, and Pastry Menu

Custom cakes start at $35 for small single-layer cakes and run $60 to $150 for larger tiered cakes depending on size, design complexity, and filling choices. Most custom orders require at least 48 hours' notice, though the bakery sometimes accommodates rush requests for an upcharge if capacity allows. Flavor options include vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, carrot, and seasonal specials; filling choices typically include buttercream, cream cheese, chocolate, and fruit compotes. Specialty requests like sugar-free or allergen-friendly cakes are possible but should be discussed directly with the bakery.

Daily pastry items range from $2.50 to $8 per piece. This includes croissants, Danish pastries, brownies, cookies, and muffins. Pricing is stable year-round, though ingredient availability can shift what appears in the case. Mini cupcakes sell for $2 each or $12 per half-dozen box, making them practical for small office gatherings or personal indulgence.

How ShortyCakes Compares to Other Oklahoma City Bakeries

ShortyCakes occupies middle ground between high-volume commercial bakeries and made-to-order-only operations. Unlike larger chains such as grocery store bakeries, ShortyCakes maintains direct contact with customers on custom orders and uses fresher ingredients in smaller batches. Unlike purely custom studios that work by appointment only, ShortyCakes maintains a walk-in pastry counter, so you can grab a croissant or cupcake without planning ahead. Competing local options include Nothing Bundt Cakes, which focuses exclusively on bundts and has more locations but less design flexibility for non-bundt cakes, and Goro Ramen + Izakaya, which offers a dessert menu but is not primarily a bakery. For event cakes requiring artistic detail or custom flavors, ShortyCakes is more accessible than ordering online from a regional cake supplier.

Who ShortyCakes Suits and Who It Does Not

ShortyCakes works best for customers who need a custom cake with 2 to 7 days' lead time and want direct conversation about design and flavor. It also serves people who prefer fresh daily pastries over mass-produced options and don't mind paying slightly more for that difference. The walk-in pastry counter makes it suitable for a coffee break or quick treat.

It is not the right choice if you need a cake within 24 hours with no exceptions, want extremely elaborate sugar-work sculpture cakes (which require specialized sculptural training beyond the bakery's typical scope), or need a very large tiered cake for 200+ guests (the kitchen's production capacity is limited to small-to-medium events). For very large weddings, a specialized wedding cake studio or catering kitchen is more appropriate.

What the First Visit Involves

Walk in and survey the pastry case, which typically displays 4 to 8 types of items. Prices are labeled, and you pay at the register. If you are ordering a custom cake, ask to speak with an owner or manager. They will show you a portfolio of past work, discuss flavor and filling options, and take your date, headcount estimate, and design preferences. A 50 percent deposit is required at order placement; final payment is due at pickup. Most custom orders are picked up in person rather than delivered.

Hours, Location, and Parking

ShortyCakes keeps extended hours compared to many local bakeries, typically opening at 8 a.m. and staying open until 7 p.m. Monday through Saturday, with shorter Sunday hours. Exact hours should be confirmed by phone or website, as holiday schedules and owner availability can create occasional shifts. Parking is street-level or in a small lot adjacent to the storefront. The bakery does not offer parking validation.

ShortyCakes fills a practical gap in Oklahoma City's bakery landscape by combining fresh-daily retail items with accessible custom work, avoiding both the impersonality of grocery bakeries and the appointment-only model of some specialized studios.