Katie's Pies and More in Oklahoma City: Made-to-Order Pies and Custom Cake Orders

Katie's Pies and More is a made-to-order bakery in Oklahoma City that specializes in fruit pies, cream pies, and custom cakes built around customer specifications rather than display cases. The operation runs on advance orders, meaning nothing sits on a shelf waiting to be bought; instead, customers plan ahead for holidays, events, or standing weekly orders.

What Katie's Pies and More Actually Is

This is a production bakery designed for people who know what they want before they call or visit. There are no walk-in impulse buys or grab-and-go pastries. Katie's makes pies with fillings like apple, pecan, cherry, and custard, alongside cream pies (chocolate, coconut, banana), and accepts custom cake orders with flavor and decoration choices. The volume is limited by the kitchen's capacity, so peak seasons (Thanksgiving, Christmas, spring events) often require orders weeks in advance.

Menu, Pricing, and Typical Order Sizes

Fruit pies and cream pies generally range from $18 to $32 depending on size and filling complexity; pecan and specialty fruit pies tend toward the higher end. Custom cakes start around $30 for sheet sizes and scale upward with tier count and decoration detail. Pricing should be confirmed directly, as ingredient costs shift seasonally. Most customers order a whole pie or cake rather than individual slices; the bakery does not offer by-the-slice service. Minimum order lead time is typically one to two weeks, though this depends on current demand and available oven space.

How Katie's Pies Compares to Other Oklahoma City Bakeries

Katie's Pies and More occupies a different slot than drop-in bakeries like local chains or grocery-store in-house bakeries. It functions more like Cattlemen's Steakhouse or other made-to-order businesses: you plan, you order, you pick up. This works best for anyone needing a specific flavor combination, dietary accommodation, or design element that assembly-line operations cannot match. For someone wanting a pie this afternoon, it will not work. For someone with a Thanksgiving table or wedding shower two weeks out, it is more reliable than hoping a generic bakery has the exact thing in stock. Customers comparing Katie's to a supermarket bakery should expect higher quality and customization; customers comparing it to chain cake shops should expect more personalized attention and less corporate standardization.

Who This Suits, and Who It Does Not

Order-ahead bakeries suit people who plan events, celebrate holidays with intention, or have strong flavor preferences. Parents preparing for school bake sales (with advance notice), hosts throwing sit-down dinners, and anyone with dietary restrictions benefit from the custom-order model. The setup does not work for impulse visits, last-minute needs, or people who prefer seeing a finished product before paying. It also requires a phone call or in-person visit to place an order; there is no online ordering system mentioned.

What a First Visit Involves

Call or visit Katie's Pies and More to discuss your pie or cake idea. Bring details: desired flavors, size, occasion, and any decoration preferences or dietary needs. The baker will confirm availability based on current orders and your deadline. You will pay at that time or upon pickup. Pickup is typically arranged for a specific date and time. Do not expect to browse a display case; your conversation with the baker is the menu.

Hours, Location, and Logistics

Verify current hours and location by calling ahead, as made-to-order bakeries sometimes keep limited front-counter hours and operate primarily on appointment. Parking and accessibility depend on the exact address, which should be confirmed when you call to place an order. Lead times should also be confirmed when contacting the bakery, as these shift during major holidays.

Katie's Pies and More serves a specific customer: someone with a pie or cake vision and time to plan. In a city where convenience often wins, a baker willing to build something exactly as you describe it stands out.