Twice But Nice in Oklahoma City: High-End Consignment Without the Wait

Twice But Nice is a single-location consignment shop in Oklahoma City that buys and resells gently used clothing, accessories, and shoes from contemporary and designer brands, positioning itself between fast-fashion thrift stores and full-price retail for shoppers who want recognizable labels at 40 to 60 percent below original retail.

What Twice But Nice actually is

The store operates on a traditional consignment model: customers bring in unworn or lightly worn items with original tags intact, and the shop splits proceeds 50/50 after the item sells. Unlike donation-based thrift chains, consignment at Twice But Nice means pieces are vetted for condition and brand before hitting the floor, which shapes both inventory and pricing. The shop carries contemporary designer and bridge brands (think J.Crew, Banana Republic, Coach, and similar price points) rather than high-luxury or vintage rarities. Inventory turns regularly because consignment stock is actively managed; items that don't move within 60 to 90 days typically return to the consigner or are donated.

Services and pricing

Consignment sellers can bring in items year-round during business hours. The shop accepts clothing in sizes XS through XL, handbags, shoes, and accessories. Items must be from the current or prior two seasons, machine-washable or dry-clean ready without visible wear, and presented on hangers or properly folded. A 50/50 split is standard; the store handles pricing, tagging, and sales. Payouts happen when an item sells, not upfront, which differs from buy-it-now secondhand shops. On the buyer side, prices typically range from $8 to $35 for basics and everyday wear, $25 to $60 for outerwear and structured pieces, and $15 to $40 for shoes and bags. Specific prices vary by brand and condition; a Banana Republic blazer might land at $28, while a Coach crossbody bag could be $45. The shop does not price-match or negotiate.

How it compares to other Oklahoma City options

Oklahoma City's secondhand retail spans three distinct models. Thrift chains like Goodwill and Salvation Army offer volume and price ($2 to $8 per item typically) but no curation, meaning racks require heavy sorting. Consignment shops like Twice But Nice filter by brand and condition, so shopping is faster and items carry some quality assurance; the tradeoff is higher per-item cost and less volume. Online resale platforms (Poshmark, Depop, ThredUP) offer convenience and often lower prices on specific items but require shipping time and digital navigation. Twice But Nice suits someone who wants a curated floor, same-day access, and the ability to try things on without the chaos of general thrift. It doesn't suit budget hunters seeking $3 jeans or collectors hunting vintage pieces from the 1970s or earlier.

Who it suits and who it does not

Twice But Nice works well for professionals who rotate seasonal wardrobes and want to consign items that no longer fit or suit their style without donating them for nothing. It appeals to budget-conscious shoppers who recognize brand names and want familiar quality at a discount, and to people who prefer browsing in person over scrolling apps. Parents rotating children's clothing also benefit from the consignment model, though Twice But Nice carries adult sizes only. It does not suit shoppers seeking designer luxury (Hermès, Chanel) or vintage collectibles, and it is not ideal for someone on an extremely tight budget who can find comparable basics at a general thrift store for half the price.

What the first visit involves

Browsers can walk in during open hours without appointment. The store is organized by clothing type (tops, bottoms, dresses, outerwear) and size, with a small accessories and shoe section. Items are tagged with brand, size, price, and condition notes. The shop is small enough to survey in 15 to 20 minutes. Consigners should bring items on hangers in a bag or box, with original tags attached if possible. The staff will inspect pieces for damage, stains, or wear and tell you on the spot whether they accept the batch. Accepted items are priced and placed on the floor within a few days.

Hours, parking, and logistics

Twice But Nice operates in a small retail strip with street-level parking; verify current hours by calling ahead, as consignment shops sometimes shift seasonal hours. There is no online inventory list, so repeat visits are typical for shoppers hunting specific sizes or styles. The shop does not ship or hold items; returns are cash or store credit at the consigner's request.

Twice But Nice fills a practical middle ground in Oklahoma City's secondhand market for anyone willing to pay slightly more per item in exchange for curation and recognizable brands.