Play It Again Sports in Oklahoma City: New and Used Soccer Gear at Resale Prices

Play It Again Sports is a used and new sporting goods retailer specializing in soccer equipment, apparel, and footwear at prices 30 to 50 percent below retail. Located on Northwest Expressway, it operates on a buy-sell-trade model where customers can offload outgrown or unused gear while shopping inventory that rotates weekly based on what locals bring in.

What Play It Again Sports Actually Is

Play It Again Sports occupies a middle position between big-box retailers and specialty soccer boutiques. It stocks new merchandise from brands like Nike, Adidas, and Puma alongside used cleats, shin guards, socks, and training wear. The used inventory makes it especially useful for families with young players who outgrow equipment every season, or for adults testing a new position or league without full investment. Stock changes constantly; an Adidas Predator cleat in size 5 one week may be gone the next, but another brand will replace it.

Pricing and Trade Structure

New soccer cleats at Play It Again Sports run $35 to $80, compared to $90 to $180 at Dick's Sporting Goods or specialty shops. Used cleats average $15 to $45 depending on condition and brand. shin guards are $8 to $20 used, $15 to $35 new. Training shirts and shorts run $5 to $15 used, $12 to $30 new. The buy-sell-trade system lets you deposit used gear for store credit (typically 40 to 60 percent of resale value) or cash at a lower rate; credit usually arrives faster than cash payout. Bring items clean and in wearable condition; heavily worn or stained gear may be declined.

How It Compares to Other Oklahoma City Options

Dick's Sporting Goods on Penn Avenue carries new soccer equipment from the same major brands but at full retail price with seasonal sales. Its inventory is predictable and restocked weekly, making it better if you need a specific item guaranteed in stock. Academy Sports + Outdoors locations stock basic soccer cleats and apparel but with a narrower range and lower quality than Dick's. Play It Again Sports beats both on price for budget-conscious families and on unique finds, but inventory is unpredictable; if you need a particular cleat model in a specific size, Dick's is more reliable. Specialty soccer shops like those inside the Oklahoma City metro serve competitive players willing to pay $150+ for premium models; Play It Again Sports serves recreational players and families.

Who It Suits and Who It Does Not

Play It Again Sports works best for parents outfitting young players in the U-8 to U-12 range, recreational adult league players, or anyone testing a new position. The trade-in option makes it financially sensible when kids' feet grow a full size every year. It also suits budget-conscious coaches buying bulk shin guards or pinnies for teams. It does not work well for players needing exact color coordination for a uniform, competitive U-16+ players seeking premium boots, or anyone on a tight timeline; the lack of guarantees on specific inventory and the need to dig through racks makes it slow. New merchandise does come in regularly, but used stock is first-come, first-served.

What the First Visit Involves

Arrive ready to browse racks organized loosely by item type (cleats, apparel, shin guards, socks, goalkeeper gloves). Staff can point you toward used vs. new sections but do not typically curate selections. If you bring used gear to trade, bring it in original condition; staff will inspect it for wear, stains, and functionality (test cleats for sole separation or torn uppers). Trade estimates happen on the spot, with payout in store credit or a mailed check. Plan 20 to 30 minutes for a casual browse, longer if you are hunting a specific size or brand.

Hours, Parking, and Logistics

Play It Again Sports operates Monday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 7 p.m., and Sunday 12 p.m. to 5 p.m. (verify current hours before visiting, as retail hours can shift). Parking is street-level and ample. The location sits on Northwest Expressway between Penn and Western avenues, accessible from I-44. No appointment needed; walk-ins are standard. Online inventory is not available, so you cannot call ahead to confirm a specific cleat in stock.

Play It Again Sports fills a practical gap for Oklahoma City families and recreational players by making seasonal gear replacements affordable and by accepting trade-ins that keep usable equipment in circulation rather than landfilled.