Play It Again Sports in Oklahoma City: Used and New Athletic Gear at Half Retail

Play It Again Sports is a buy-sell-trade athletic retailer occupying a standalone storefront in the northwest quadrant, stocking gently used and new sports equipment, apparel, and footwear across multiple disciplines at 40 to 60 percent below department store prices.

What Play It Again Sports actually is

This is a consignment-hybrid model rather than a traditional resale shop. The store accepts used gear on consignment from customers, purchases overstock and returned merchandise from other retailers, and stocks new closeout inventory alongside its own-brand basics. The result is a rotating inventory where you might find a pair of Nike running shoes priced at $45 (used, good condition) next to a new Champion hoodie at $18. The operation runs lean on staff but high on turnover, meaning popular sizes in running shoes, soccer cleats, and gym apparel move within weeks.

Inventory by sport and typical pricing

Running shoes dominate the floor space. Used pairs typically range from $25 to $65 depending on wear; new returns or overstock start at $40. Hiking boots and trail runners occupy a smaller section with used options at $30 to $80. Soccer and football cleats appear intermittently and at $20 to $55 used. Gym apparel (t-shirts, shorts, tights) runs $5 to $20 used and $8 to $25 new. Outerwear (jackets, fleece) costs $15 to $50 used and $25 to $70 new. The store also carries basic accessories: socks, belts, gym bags, and water bottles at $2 to $15. Brand availability shifts weekly because consignment stock depends on what locals bring in; calling ahead before a specific brand hunt saves a wasted trip.

How it compares to Dick's Sporting Goods and department store clearance

Dick's Sporting Goods, located on the south side near major retail clusters, stocks all new inventory at full to mid-season pricing (running shoes $80 to $140, apparel $30 to $60). Their advantage is guaranteed selection, fit expertise, and return policies. Play It Again competes on price alone. A runner looking for a second pair of trainers for cross-training, or a parent outfitting a child who will outgrow cleats in one season, finds better value here. Department store clearance sections (Macy's, Kohl's) occasionally undercut Play It Again on brand-name apparel, but their selection rotates quarterly and their shoe inventory is minimal. Play It Again's constant flow of consignment stock means something new arrives weekly, and the used-gear angle eliminates the risk of buying shoes that don't perform for your gait.

Who it suits and who it does not

This works best for budget-conscious runners, casual athletes, parents of youth sports players, and gym-goers willing to inspect merchandise for wear. Thrift-minded shoppers accustomed to hunting through racks will find the pace rewarding. It does not suit someone needing immediate access to a specific size or model in premium brands, or athletes who need professional shoe fitting (Play It Again staff do not gait-analyze). First-time buyers of technical gear (moisture-wicking shirts, compression shorts) may struggle because the consignment stock does not guarantee breadth of options in every category.

What the first visit involves

Walk in and scan racks by sport (running, soccer, basketball, general gym) or by type (shoes, apparel, outerwear). Most used items are tagged with the original brand price crossed out and the Play It Again price in marker. Inspect shoes for sole wear, creasing, and odor; most stock is good to very good condition, but a pair sitting for months may show dust. Try on shoes in the small fitting area near the register. Checkout is straightforward; there is no membership or loyalty program. If you want to consign gear, bring clean, unworn or lightly worn athletic items in original packaging or near-original condition. The store takes 40 percent commission on consignment sales; you collect your share monthly or let it build as store credit.

Hours, parking, and access

The store operates Monday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 7 p.m., and Sunday 12 p.m. to 5 p.m. (verify current hours, as retail schedules shift seasonally). It sits in a small strip center with ample surface lot parking directly in front; no parking fees or validation systems. The storefront is accessible from the main road, making it a quick stop during errands rather than a destination requiring navigation through a mall.

Play It Again Sports fills a price gap for Oklahoma City shoppers who want athletic gear below mall markup but cannot wait for seasonal clearance events or online shipping. The consignment model keeps prices fluid and turns inventory fast enough to reward repeat visits.