Mathis Brothers Furniture in Oklahoma City: Locally-Owned Mid-Range Upholstery and Case Goods
Mathis Brothers is a single-location, family-operated furniture retailer on NW 23rd Street that stocks upholstered seating, wooden dining tables, bedroom sets, and accent pieces at prices positioned between big-box chains and high-end independent showrooms.
What Mathis Brothers Actually Is
The store occupies roughly 40,000 square feet and carries in-stock and made-to-order furniture across multiple categories. Unlike Ashley Furniture HomeStore locations, which emphasize value-tier inventory and fast turnover, or independent design studios that custom-build everything to spec, Mathis Brothers balances ready-to-purchase floor stock with the ability to order upholstered pieces in customer-selected fabrics. The inventory leans toward traditional and transitional styling; contemporary and industrial lines are present but not the primary focus. Ownership remains within the Mathis family, a distinction that shapes staffing consistency and willingness to hold price negotiations on larger purchases.
Selection, Price Tiers, and Delivery
Sofas and sectionals range from $800 for basic track-arm designs to $2,400 for leather sectionals with motorized recliners. Dining tables run $600 to $1,800 depending on size and material (solid wood versus veneer top). Bedroom sets, including dresser and nightstands, typically fall between $1,200 and $2,500. Custom upholstery orders usually take 6 to 10 weeks; floor samples ship within 1 to 2 weeks.
Delivery is included for purchases over $1,500 within Oklahoma City proper and covers basic room placement. Delivery to surrounding suburbs incurs a $100 to $200 surcharge. Assembly of beds and dining tables is included; upholstered pieces arrive fully assembled. Removal of old furniture is available for $150 to $350 per room, depending on quantity.
This pricing structure positions Mathis Brothers above Wayfair and Overstock (which offer faster shipping but no in-store consultation or trial) and below Haverty Furniture (which carries higher-end upholstery and custom-order minimums of $3,000 or more).
How It Compares Locally
Ashley Furniture HomeStore locations in the OKC metro undercut Mathis Brothers on entry-level upholstered sofas by 10 to 15 percent and emphasize rapid delivery (often 2 to 4 weeks), but fabric and frame quality tend toward budget-grade. Haverty, with a location on Quail Springs Parkway, offers deeper customization and higher-quality hardwoods and down-wrapped cushions but requires longer lead times and carries few pieces under $2,000. Rooms to Go, near The Outlets of Oklahoma City, caters to buyers seeking complete room sets with financing; their quality-to-price ratio favors speed and bulk volume over durability.
Mathis Brothers suits buyers who want to examine upholstery in person, negotiate on larger orders, and expect delivery and placement from a staff that has worked together for years. It does not serve those seeking ultra-fast shipping or the lowest possible price on basics.
Who It Suits and Who It Does Not
This store works well for homeowners furnishing a living room or dining room with mid-range upholstery and those willing to wait 6 to 10 weeks for custom-ordered pieces in specific fabrics. It also suits families moving to Oklahoma City from out of state and needing consultation on layout and style pairing.
It is not ideal for renters needing temporary solutions, buyers working on a per-week budget timeline, or those exclusively shopping online based on images. Design services are minimal; the store does not offer in-home consultations or CAD renderings of room schemes.
First Visit and Logistics
Expect to spend 45 minutes to an hour on a first visit. Salespeople typically ask about room dimensions, existing decor, and timeline rather than pushing immediate purchase. Floor stock can be tested (sofas have firm, medium, and soft cushion options on display), and fabric swatches are available to take home. Financing through Synchrony Bank is available at promotional rates (typically 0 percent for 12 to 24 months on purchases over $1,500); terms should be confirmed at point of sale.
The showroom is open Monday through Saturday 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Sunday noon to 5 p.m. (verify current hours before visiting, as retail schedules shift seasonally). Parking is ample and free in a dedicated lot. The NW 23rd Street location is accessible from I-44 and sits near other home-goods retailers, making it convenient for a shopping afternoon.
Why It Matters
Mathis Brothers fills a practical gap between chain retailers and luxury designers, offering enough customization to feel personal without the price or timeline commitment of bespoke furniture makers. Its longevity in Oklahoma City reflects steady demand for mid-market upholstery with local accountability.
