Our Sisters' Closet in Oklahoma City: Secondhand Fashion with Consignment Sales
A consignment boutique on NW 23rd Street, Our Sisters' Closet sells used and vintage clothing, accessories, and home goods on behalf of local consignors. The shop stocks mid-range and designer pieces at 40 to 60 percent below retail, making it the closest Oklahoma City option to a curated resale experience that neither feels like a thrift outlet nor requires membership or appointment fees.
What Our Sisters' Closet actually is
Our Sisters' Closet operates on a split-revenue consignment model: customers bring in clothing and accessories they no longer wear; the shop prices and displays the items; the original owner receives 40 to 50 percent of the sale price when the piece sells, keeping the balance. This arrangement means inventory rotates constantly. The shop accepts women's apparel, shoes, bags, and jewelry in current styles and good condition, rejecting items with stains, odor, or significant wear. Home décor and furniture pieces appear seasonally. The physical space is modest, roughly 1,200 square feet, organized by garment type rather than size alone, which requires browsing but rewards attention.
Pricing and what to expect to spend
Most dresses run $12 to $35; blazers and structured jackets, $18 to $50; designer handbags, $25 to $80 depending on brand and condition; jeans, $10 to $25. A vintage Levi's or Levi's-quality piece typically costs less than $20. Shoes range $8 to $30. Jewelry is priced individually, usually $5 to $20 for costume pieces and $15 to $60 for vintage or gold-filled items. These prices assume good condition and popular brands; rare vintage or high-end designer pieces command higher prices. Consignors should expect the shop to take 4 to 8 weeks to sell an item and will not accept returns of unsold merchandise; pieces not sold within 90 days are typically donated. Payment to consignors happens via check or store credit, with store credit incentivizing repeat visits.
How it compares to other Oklahoma City resale options
Crossroads Vintage, also in Oklahoma City, focuses heavily on true vintage (1980s and earlier) and leans toward bohemian and Y2K aesthetics, with prices slightly higher ($20 to $60 for dresses) and a narrower seasonal range. Clothes Mentor, a national resale chain with two Oklahoma City locations, emphasizes fast turnover and contemporary brands, offers slightly lower price points ($8 to $20 for most items), and operates on a buy-outright rather than consignment model, meaning no waiting for payment. Buffalo Exchange, a multi-location resale chain, buys used items outright and also sells vintage; it carries more clothing volume per square foot but with less curation. Our Sisters' Closet sits between these: more editorial than Clothes Mentor or Buffalo Exchange, with stronger designer placement and seasonal home goods, but broader in style than Crossroads Vintage and without the appointment or markup of high-end consignment services. Choose Our Sisters' Closet if you want curated contemporary and near-contemporary pieces at thrift-adjacent prices; choose Crossroads if you specifically want true vintage; choose Clothes Mentor if you value speed and brand-name contemporary labels.
Who this suits and who it does not
Our Sisters' Closet works best for shoppers hunting specific item types (a structured blazer, ankle boots, a leather bag) who have time to browse and are comfortable with variable inventory. It suits consignors who own quality pieces they've outgrown but don't want to photograph and list individually. It does not suit shoppers on a rigid timeline looking for guaranteed stock, nor does it work for consignors expecting fast payment or high percentages of retail price. Anyone seeking ethical fast-fashion alternatives will find the resale model attractive; anyone wanting the convenience of a traditional retail transaction should look elsewhere.
What the first visit involves
Walk in without appointment. Spend 20 to 45 minutes browsing by garment type, checking seams and zippers for wear. Items are tagged with price and material content but not size alone, so trying on in the fitting room (located toward the back) is standard. The register area sits near the front. If consigning, bring items clean and on hangers; staff will evaluate them and give immediate feedback on acceptance. Consignors complete a simple form with contact and payment preference; accepted items are tagged and entered into inventory that day.
Hours, parking, and location
Our Sisters' Closet operates Tuesday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Sunday noon to 4 p.m., closed Mondays. Street parking is available on NW 23rd Street and in a small adjacent lot; the area is walkable but car-dependent. Hours change seasonally; verify before a visit, especially around holidays.
Our Sisters' Closet fills a gap in Oklahoma City's resale market by offering the editorial eye of a boutique with the price transparency and regular turnover of consignment, making it essential for anyone balancing budget and style in the city.
