Burrell's Cookies & Dreams in Oklahoma City: Made-to-Order Decorated Cookies and Custom Cake Orders
Burrell's Cookies & Dreams is a custom cookie and cake bakery operating from a retail storefront in Oklahoma City, specializing in hand-decorated sugar cookies, custom sheet cakes, and cupcakes made to order for events, corporate orders, and individual purchases. The business focuses on design customization rather than high-volume production, positioning it for occasions where appearance and personalization matter as much as taste.
What Burrell's Cookies & Dreams actually is
The bakery centers on decorated sugar cookies and custom cakes rather than a walk-in pastry counter with rotating daily items. Orders are typically placed in advance, allowing the decorator to complete custom designs. The space functions part retail display, part production kitchen. Cookie designs range from simple color fills to intricate patterns, photo-transfers, and 3D elements. Cakes are available as sheet cakes in standard sizes, and the bakery also produces custom cupcake orders.
Menu, pricing, and what to order
Decorated sugar cookies start at around $2 to $4 per cookie depending on complexity, with bulk orders of 12 or more often receiving modest per-unit discounts. Custom sheet cakes (standard 8-inch or 9-inch rounds, or 9-by-13-inch sheets) typically run $25 to $50 depending on flavor, filling, and design detail. Cupcake orders begin around $3 per cupcake. Pricing varies with design intricacy, so intricate hand-painted cookies or cakes with multiple colors and fine details cost more than solid-color or two-color designs. Prices can shift seasonally, so confirmation directly with the bakery is wise for exact rates.
The most practical approach for a small event is a mixed order: two dozen decorated cookies ($40 to $80) paired with a custom sheet cake ($30 to $45). For office or school events, bulk cookie orders are economical. The cookies hold well for several days in airtight storage, making them suitable for advance preparation.
How Burrell's Cookies & Dreams compares to other Oklahoma City dessert options
Oklahoma City's custom cake and cookie market includes larger bakeries such as Cakebread Bakery, which emphasizes tiered wedding cakes and operates with longer lead times and higher price points, and smaller operations like local supermarket bakeries (Whole Foods Market, Sprouts Farmers Market), which offer faster turnaround but limited custom decoration. Crumbl Cookies, a national chain with an Oklahoma City location, provides rotating "flavor of the week" cookies at $4.25 per cookie with no customization. Burrell's occupies the middle ground: faster than Cakebread for smaller orders, more personalized than chain bakeries, and more design-intensive than grocery-store cakes. Choose Burrell's if you need a specific design, moderate lead time (typically one to two weeks for large orders), and willingness to pick up in person. Choose Cakebread for wedding or high-ceremony cakes. Choose Crumbl for immediate gratification or new-flavor experimentation.
Who Burrell's suits and who it does not
Burrell's serves parents ordering cookies for school events, offices needing branded or themed desserts, small-wedding cake orders, birthday celebrations with specific character or design requests, and anyone wanting custom decoration on baked goods. The custom-order model means planning ahead, not impulse purchase. Customers should be comfortable with lead times of 3 to 7 days for standard orders, longer for peak seasons. The bakery does not suit someone seeking a walk-in grab of pastries or cakes. It suits customers with a clear design vision and flexibility on pickup timing.
What the first visit involves
Contact the bakery by phone or social media (most small Oklahoma City bakeries operate primarily by direct messaging or phone) to discuss your order idea. Describe the occasion, number of servings, flavor preferences, and design concept. The baker will either confirm availability and pricing or suggest adjustments. You will pick up your order at the scheduled time. Bring a box or container if you plan to transport delicate decorated cookies. Payment is typically due at pickup or partially at order confirmation.
Hours, location, and logistics
Confirm current hours and location directly with Burrell's before visiting, as small bakeries sometimes adjust hours seasonally. The business is located within Oklahoma City proper. Parking depends on the storefront location; call ahead to understand parking availability if you plan a walk-in inquiry. Orders are placed by phone or social media rather than online ordering systems, so expect to speak with the baker directly about your design.
Burrell's Cookies & Dreams holds a clear role for Oklahoma City residents seeking personalized baked goods at a price point below full-service wedding bakeries and with more design control than chain or grocery alternatives. The custom-order model requires planning but delivers specificity that off-the-shelf desserts cannot.
